Just okay. I got two huge pieces of fish in my meal, and while the size was impressive, I can still taste the first piece I ate 5 hours after I've finished my meal. WAY too fishy. The second piece was better but my impression was tainted by the fishy first piece. I didn't get the shrimp but my table mates did and they looked delicious. Fries were also just ok. Tartar sauce was really good, but didn't redeem everything else. Next time I'm at NY NY and need to eat, I'll get a sandwich from the deli.