I come to the epicure a few times a year after being introduced to the place in 2011. No matter the time, we always manage to find a booth/patio space for our party of 5-8 people. This place is HUGE, and the quiet storefront is at times a little misleading. If possible I suggest that you get a table upstairs, either by the window or in the patio. This goes double if you want a more quiet and intimate experience (first dates/anniversaries).
I know that some have trouble with the meat dishes here, either being overcooked or just plain boring, but for the most part my experience here mainly revolves around pizza, pasta, salads and desserts. All are perfectly seasoned and fresh, the pizza here is always amazing and is cheaper than most entrees for some reason. Beer and wine are a little on the pricey side, but that's okay. Service quality is always excellent, and I have had nothing but great experiences so far.