If half stars were available, I'd probably jump this up to a 2.5, but that's about as high as I can go.
The short version of the review is that there are a lot (a LOT) of amazing restaurants in Cleveland where you can get amazing food and an amazing experience and this place just isn't cutting it.
Longer version: I can't tell of they have high prices just to seem exclusive and build up a reputation, but the dining experience we had doesn't justify the price tag.
The service was fine, but certainly not fine dining quality. Frankly, it took away from the experience and made the high price plain insulting. Of three diners each getting a drink, appetizer, main and dessert, only one entree and one dessert was deemed really good. Everything else was burnt, underseasoned, bland, misrepresented or otherwise disappointing.
Thankfully, there are dozens of other restaurants in town that really know how to provide a diner with a positive experience.