I've been to Brocach plenty of times over the years, but hadn't been for months until recently. I can't really remember having a bad meal, and usually enjoy the food.
The downtown location is looking a little rough, and could really use some updating. That peeling paint on the ceiling of the bar area looks pretty terrible.
The meal I had the other night consisted of a cup of potato leek soup (always delicious) and a couple handful of my friend's decked-out fries, which were fine. Another friend's fish sandwich look alright, but he said the curry sauce was dreadful and the fish was mediocre. He struggled to finish it. A pulled pork sandwich was also ordered, which was fine and dandy.
Will probably stop back in the future. I've had their shepherd's pie a few times, and it was always good. A few of my friends have had birthday shindigs at the downtown location over the years, and it's always been a good time.
It's a bit pricey, but a decent option.