Teddy treats everyone who comes in the door like a best friend and he does not want his friends going away disappointed, so tell him what you want and he will do his best to see you leave happy.
I've been a Teddy's customer for 10+ years ever since I first noticed his original location on The Plaza while driving home when working downtown. When that location close to my delight they moved even closer to my house. My wife and I get carryout at least 3-4 times a month. Pizza, hot dogs; pasta dinners; subs, wings are all good..
Don't go in looking for a gourmet pizza with goat cheese, pesto or sun dried tomatoes. However, for what he does Teddy is the best in the neighborhood. Thin crust with extra pepperoni and cheese is my normal order. :)