I had my Buckeye donut the morning after I got it. I really need to go back to try a fresh donut and all their other flavors.
What really struck me was how well the flavors complemented each other. The chocolate glaze was not overly sweet, and its bitterness paired well with the sweet, peanut-buttery cream. The sprinkle of chopped nuts lent additional texture. The donut itself wasn't helped by sitting for a day, which assures me it is fresh, but the center was still soft and melted in my mouth. Again, I need to try a fresh one.
The staff were also super friendly, and the environment at The Pub Chip Shop can't be beat!