After trying more of their menu (burger, wings, fish and chips) I am upping my rating to 3-stars because the food is all respectable. The service, however, is still very lacking if it is at all busy (like during Sunday football).
I am a server and I have worked in a busy sports bar before so I understand the challenges of serving in this style of restaurant, but the consistency of the poor service is cause for concern. Sit at the bar if you can find room and the service is much better. They also have a $5 off your bill offer with a yelp check in.