I have always been on the fence with this place, some visits have been great while others have been horrible. My overall opinion is just "meh".
The food is bar food, it's ok but nothing spectacular. The atmosphere can be really fun depening on the night. I think this is the best part of this whole place. They have really good specials via their social media channels but I have been twice now where I had to argue to get the deal because these specials weren't communicated to the employees that night.
If you're looking for a cool spot to hang out casually or pre game before a night out then McFadden's is cool. Just make sure to like and follow them so you can get in on their specials.