This is an iconic place for anyone from the area or if you went to school at UW Madison. I hadn't been for about 20 years. The location has changed but the food...ohhhh the food. The burgers were ammmaazzziinng everything was but the burgers stood out. I consider myself to be somewhat of a burger connoisseur and this place definitely makes my top five list.
We shared the fried mushrooms which were good, not the best I've ever had but definitely up there. We had the green and gold burger, the melting pot burger, and a bison burger with just tomatoes and lettuce. We shared a basket of fries. Out of all the burgers the bison and melting pot were the top picks.
The service was 4.5 stars all the way. She seemed really busy and there were times when the wait was a bit long feeling but what lacked in promotness was made up for with her kindness and she just seemed to really like/enjoy her job.