Oh man, this place was great! We had reservations for Saturday night and got in without any problem or wait. We sat at the cute little bar and had fun chatting with the bartender and a couple of other nearby patrons.
The drink list is extensive and they all look great. We started with a couple of mai tais and then went with another rum based drink that had some pineapple in it. I'm not sure what it was called but it was fantastic.
Finally, I have to say, we originally had an unexpected problem with our original reservation time and the owner Rich was so accommodating in helping us change the time for our visit. Rich and his crew provided an amazing experience and I can't wait to come back and tell all my friends about Undertow.