Don't leave Stumpy's with takeout without checking your order.
In the 17 years I've been in Phoenix the only good pizza I've found is Pizzeria Bianco. I keep looking for decent pizza that is more accessible and less expensive. Read the reviews here and decided to try Stumpy's.
First disappointment - I ordered online for takeout and was charged roughly $2.50 extra for the privilege of ordering online. They ought to give discounts for that.
Second disappointment - the pizza. Ordered a large with ground sausage, mushrooms and black olives. We got home and discovered that we had a large with pepperoni, some mushrooms, and a few scattered molecules of sausage. No olives. We don't hate pepperoni, but we don't like it either and we didn't order it because we didn't want it. We tried to remove it but it was the bottom layer and they were VERY generous with the ingredient we didn't want. It literally appeared as if they took a pre-made pepperoni pizza and tossed a little mushroom and sausage on it rather than make the pizza we ordered. We love black olives, which was why we ordered them. Other than the fact that the crust was limp we can't say what the pizza is like - we could taste nothing but pepperoni, and we didn't like it.
Third disappointment - the salad. It has it's good points - the lettuce was fresh, but it was all ribs, no leaves. It has things your usual side salad doesn't have - green peppers, mushroms, black olives - yeah, there were a lot of them in the salad, none on the pizza - but the salad would be improved by the addition of other standard items oddly missing at Stumpy's - carrot and red cabbage.
I doubt if we will try Stumpy's again, but if we do we won't order online, we won't leave without checking that we got the pizza we ordered rather than someone else's leftover pepperoni pizza, and we will skip the salad.