My friend recently had a birthday, and was able to get a reservation here same day, which was great! I was excited to go, since I had been wanting to try this place for awhile. The space is warm and inviting, and does make you feel like you are in a tropical bar (even when it is only 20 degrees out!). We had a corner space at the front, with a comfy couch and ottomans with a central coffee table for our drinks. My friend brought a cake from the Oakmont Bakery, and the staff didn't mind at all and even provided plates and utensils.
The cocktail menu is extensive and unique with a lot of island-themed drinks. My friends' drinks arrived in large shells illuminated red with some kind of waterproof light (nice touch). Since I am allergic to pineapple I went to the bar and ordered a custom drink, requesting Amaro with a slightly sweet mixer. The drink came out and I was told it had rye whiskey. Since I do enjoy a good rye I didn't mind, but I would have liked the drink I actually requested (and I didn't feel like being "that person" who returns her drink repeatedly). Since it was tasty I didn't mind, and simply ordered straight amaro on the rocks for my next drink.
We stayed for a few hours, and enjoyed the evening. The noise level is adequate and the service quick, so it is a great place for a night out with friends. But I think that I will stick to Bar Marco or Meat and Potatoes for a quality cocktail.