Coming from a town where you either eat Osso's Pizza or Hill House pizza I can understand the fact that this is a pizza you either like or hate.
Let's just say, I like it. I like the crust it's puffy and crisp around the edges, I like the sauce as well. It's sweet and not very jam like. And Carolyne, the cheese doesn't taste like rubber, just for the record.
Walking into Pizza Shack, which has incredibly limited hours, I loved it instantly. It's a little dark, really old and it says to me "I've been here a long time, and there's a good reason for that."
Good and simple. The way things should be. From better times.