I gave Kilt & Caber two chances, and experience was consistent - "meh". Not really "eww", but certainly "meh"...
Sticky tables? Checked. Stench in the air? Checked. Worn out furniture? Checked. Pitifully brief choice of beers? Checked.
But what really kills the place is clientele - think Hells Angels wannabes - and service. While bikers are occasional, service is consistent - and consistently slow. As in - slow motion! With the room half empty it took me from twenty minutes to half an hour from seat to get food.
And kitchen work is actually pretty good, by the way - not something to crave, but quite reasonably good. Even servers were rather friendly when they helped - keyword is "when", though. That felt like once in a lifetime opportunity.
So I'm disappointed by the place - was ignoring it for a while, then had a chance to try, and oh well... Frankly, I'd recommend Brewsters (just around the corner) instead of Kilt & Caber for a bar choice in the area.