The four of us stopped in at 3 p.m. on a Saturday afternoon and were promptly informed they wouldn't be serving food until 5 p.m. So, we were warned. We got a table and had several glasses of wine or beer. At 5 p.m., we ordered a bunch of different apps and meals. I tried the nachos, beer cheese soup, cheese curds and chicken tenders. None of them were very impressive. Then we got the bill, which was $200, including tip. That means we each ate/drank $50 worth of food and alcohol. (I had two glasses of wine, chicken strips and soup). Then I thought about what I could get for that same amount of money at other restaurants/brewpubs, and what we got at Long Girl wasn't worth what we paid (in my opinion).
I get that they want to be known as a brewery first and restaurant second. So narrow down your menu and focus on doing a few dishes right and charge reasonable prices.
I will say the service was excellent and the ambiance/decor was great.