NYPD does it right. Pizza, that is. I haven't actually tried any of their other food because the pizza is so freakin good. PERFECT doughy crust just crisp enough on the outside and soft on the inside, flavorful tomato sauce, and the ratio of cheese to sauce is spot on. When my parents visit from NY and want pizza that is like home, we go here.
Like the other reviewer said, the Pizza Blanco is to die for...big gooey chunks of ricotta and fresh roma tomatoes (or spinach) and an s-load of garlic.
I dine in and get takeout from here pretty regularly, and I think the pizza is slightly better as takeout because it has more time to rest. When you can get it home you can fold that sweet slice in half and dig in. It is nice to have a fresh from the oven pizza in the restaurant, but if the cheese is not set up at least a little, you can have kind of a messy slice that requires a fork. As far as pizza goes in this neighborhood, NYPD (and occasionally AJ's by the slice) is the only way to go.