As a New Yorker, I am pretty skeptical of any pizza places outside of my home state, thinking they can't taste as good.
When I lived here, I used to frequent NYPD Pizza but last I visited them, they went waaaaay downhill.
Decided to try Yo Pauly's after reading the reviews on Yelp and I was not disappointed. While I have had better pizza, it was still on par with many pizzza places back home. We had one plain pie and one pineapple pie and I thought both were good.
Would definitely order a takeout pie from here again next time I am in town.