For a consistently good pizza, Wolfman is our top choice in the area. The restaurant has interesting decor, although is a bit small, which isn't a problem for us as we tend to carryout or have the food delivered. The delivery almost always occurs prior to the timeline given, and the delivery guy has always been very friendly.
Wolfman pizza really is the best in the Cotswold area, and the breadsticks with three dip options are also very good. We generally get a salad with our meal (have to throw in some greens for at least a small attempt at healthiness), and the greek salad with dressing is a solid choice. We've tried the pepperoni, extra cheese, and the veggie pizza and have not been disappointed. On top of pizza, there is an extensive menu of pasta and sandwich options, which we've yet to try as the pizza is always so good.
Only downside is that Wolfman doesn't really offer "deals" like some of the other chains, so can be a bit pricey. But if you're looking for good pizza and breadsticks, and don't mind paying full price, the Wolfman in Cotswold is the place to go.