What can I say that hasn't already said about The Old Fashioned? Probably nothing.
This might be Madison's most popular restaurant. I'm genuinely surprised when it's not full and people don't seem to have a problem waiting an hour to get in.
Pros:
-Top notch service
-Sets the standards for Madison's bar food scene
-Excellent atmosphere that's the right balance of kitsch and class
Cons:
-Man, this place is always busy. Expect a wait for a table.