From the moment you walk into this quaint shop .. you can cleary see that Baldwin Burger is run by passionate, young owners that put a priority on quality, and locally sourced products. It's clear they care about, and are proud of what they serve.
My family lives within walking distance, and have eaten there at least a dozen times. Paired with some Kawartha Ice Cream just around the corner it makes for a nice quiet evening.
My wife rotates between a number of their burgers (French Onion, Mushroom, and Caesar), but always gets the fried pickles and a water. I swear by their Buffalo Wing burger, and love the fries with a nice cold Boylan's Black Cherry soda.
You can get a cheaper burger in Whitby/Brooklin area, but it certainly won't be as tasty. Won't be grass fed local beef ... and won't have their blue cheese aioli on it (that stuff, made in-house .. is awesome)
However, note .. they are closed Monday, and Tuesday. When I questioned the owner, he was quick to say they want to keep quality controls on all the food and prep. The owners use those days to prepare for the week and ensure they keep to their very high food standards.
I would highly recommend Baldwin Burger if you are looking for a great burger, fries/rings/pickles. Either Dine-in, or take out.