My husband and I went for the first time on a Sunday night. We really enjoyed our dinner there. Gino, our waiter, was hilarious! He was knowledgable and funny. Definitely knows how to sell desserts!
Our meals were a mixed bag. My husband had the Sicilian salad with chicken - he loved it! I had Bucket of Balls - Turkey with Carbonera sauce. Not a fan. Doesn't mean it wasn't good, the turkey flavor just didn't appeal to me personally. The Deconstructed Cannoli was FANTASTIC!
There were only two things that kept me from giving the Sicilian Butcher a five star rating; one,when this place is full, it's loud and two, I couldn't get my water glass refilled to save my butt. Petty, maybe, but important to me. That being said, we will definitely be back with family and friends.