I was pretty impressed the first time we went to 125 North Main. I ordered the salmon patties special, and got a plate filled with patties, roasted potatoes, and "custard-style" mac & cheese. It all seemed pretty good, but there were rough spots. The hush puppies had an off-putting, fishy taste to them, almost certainly deep fried in the same oil as fish. And the "roasted" potatoes... seemed to be just heated in the oven, not roasted per se. But we've been back twice since then, and it's gotten better and better every time. The CFS is delicious, some of the best I've ever had. And my GF got the roasted potatoes last time... and they were roasted.
125 also does desserts. Basically, they have a chocolate cake with homemade icing that had candy pieces crushed up in it. The Reese's was OK (too sweet and dry to my taste), the Heath Bar was pretty good (although too much of a good thing), but the Butterfinger was excellent.
Prices are completely reasonable (usually $16-$18 for two of us, including one dessert). And the sweet tea's really good, too!