I really like what Butterjoint seems to be attempting--a cocktail lounge for non-bros who actually enjoy interesting drinks. I met up with a group of friends seated in the back corner, and the server came over reasonably quickly to take my drink order. I ordered a Ninth Ward (on special for $7) and it was fantastic.
However, we were having great difficulty hearing each other over the rather loud music, and the lack of anything soft in the room made being the noise that much more intolerable. A friend asked our server if there was anything she could do, and her answer (no joke) was "Well this IS a bar."
I definitely would come back here for the delicious cocktails, but if you're trying to attract people who aren't ordering PBR, let them chat and enjoy their drinks. Butterjoint needs to work a bit harder on allowing the atmosphere to match the high-quality pours.