Jeni's is one of the best ice cream experiences I have had. The flavors were creative without being over-the-top or pretentious; I particularly remember the cayenne/dark chocolate and honey/pistachio. Best of all, the ice cream was just perfectly sweet and not overly cloying. This was a clear highlight of my evening in Chagrin Falls.
It should also be pointed out that they have very respectable french press coffee.