My friends like The Parlor more than I do.
That's not to say it's sub-par, but rather they gush about it so profusely that there's no way it can live up to the hype. (Note: I talk about expectations a lot because it's half the dining experience.)
I've had the pizza and the duck club. Both are very good. The setting is nice and the location is about perfect. I like the patio and bar area more than the main dining room.
My reasons for a 3 instead of a 4 or higher? The prices strike me as about 15 percent higher than they should be. And the staff has never blown me away. My last waiter was extremely goofy and unapologetically slow, especially since it wasn't even a capacity crowd.
The Parlor is one of those places that I'll continue to visit every now and again because a) The experience will probably never be awful; and b) my friends and family often call the shots.
Hence, a solid 3-star rating.