So my favorite pizza is New York style, but I have to say, this pizza was delicious!! Went there with my hubby, son, and mom- and dad-in-law. Ordered The Malnati Chicago Classic and a classic pepperoni. Both with the butter crust (I mean, if you're going to do deep dish, you may as well go all the way). We added mushrooms to the Malnati, too.
Crust was wonderful as promised, nicely offsetting the fresh and savory sauce and the perfect amount of cheese and meat. My mouth is watering as I remember it. Great craft beer or wine to go along with it. I tend to be a purest and would order just a pepperoni wherever I go, so I preferred the pepperoni, but I enjoyed both. Waitress was awesome and the balsamic dressing for the salad was great (pizza takes a while, so salad is advised, plus, you know, it's greens).
Weirdly, my oldest son was visiting Chicago at the time and when my youngest told him he should look for this Chicago original, my oldest sent a picture of his pizza box and said he'd eaten there a few hours earlier. Thumbs up from all six of us!