I love burgers too, but still...
OK, I'm not going to be Captain Bringdown here. It wasn't BAD. Service was friendly, and wait time for our table was fairly average. Not instant, but also not waiting forever. Burger selection was good. My friend chose the Standard, and I went with the Upstream Burger, which was a salmon patty. Grilled, not fried, so bonus for that.
There wasn't much atmosphere to speak of, but at least it was clean.
And the food was acceptable. Unlike my other reviews on here, I don't particularly have any superlative adjectives for I Love Burgers. It was good. That's about it. Fries were good. Atmosphere good.
There are a lot of places I can get "good" though, and for less. Or I could go to Holsteins, Burger Bar, or one of many other places, shell out a few more bucks and get "great."
I'm not poo-poohing the place, but the only reason I can think of to really recommend it is if you're in Town Square for whatever reason, you don't want CPK, you can't afford to get Claim Jumper in your budget, and Yardhouse has a game on and you don't want to deal with the rowdies. THEN I Love Burgers might be a good choice.