I am a regular there. Hands down Rodney's has the best oyster in down. And the seafood is very fresh.
The reason I am only giving three stars because of the service. Often we wait for another 15mins even when we made a reservation. We went there this Friday, there are few new faces, I think they did not get train properly. No smile, very rude and took so long to get our bills. It was $200 for three of us.