How can you not love this place. I'm the kind of person that will rather go buy a carton of ice cream at Fry's over getting my sweet fix at an ice cream shop since you get much more for the same price, but this is the exception.
You can taste the freshness in the ice cream. It's like driving a Ford Taurus vs a Lamborghini. I always, always get the Birthday Cake ice cream, well except for tonight (it's all good Casey!). Today I got Chocolate Cake (need to stick with the extremely sugary stuff I guess) and Cookies N Cream. Equally amazing. So now I'll have to get 3 scoops every time I go.
There is a lovely inside where you can sit with friends, draw fun stuff on their chalkboard tables. They also have pints you can take home, they make really good cakes and they also make amazing butter. This is just one of those places where you feel good supporting a local business and you get a great treat in return. Also, the owner Casey is in quite often and very friendly. Today when I went in he was super excited to show off the Superstition Farm's new website.
Protip: Check in with the Yelp app and get your loyalty card punched. I've already gone through 2 and they hook it up with I think $5 worth of free treats when you get enough check-ins and/or hole punches.