Stayed here for the Madison Mini Marathon in August. Middle of the road on this one. Not really close to where I needed to be, but one of the hotels available on the website. I rented a car and drove over, apparently they had a shuttle available.
Check in was quick, no issues there. I got in later at night, and it seemed like one guy outside was looking for a fight. I got into the room no problem, plenty of space for 1 person. Didn't have a chance to try out the breakfast.
I'd recommend getting a car to get around, because it's not really close to where you need to be if you're going downtown. Additionally, I booked through the Madison Mini Marathon Website, and by doing that, I wasn't eligible for rewards points which isn't cool, but oh well. Can't change that.