Hubby and I were curious to try this place out, and shared a "sweet experience for two". Some were definitely bigger hits (marshmallow chocolate pizza) than others (vanilla ice cream -- but mainly because you're just not interesting enough when your neighbours on the dessert plate are chocolate brownie bites, chocolate wafers, and chocolate sauce) but I liked the variety.
Contrary to Juliette's (where service is a bit inconsistent -- some days I feel like that place is oozing snootiness), our server here was super helpful, friendly, and what I appreciated the most -- she didn't try to talk us into ordering more food than what we could finish. (We were considering getting the sampler AND a waffle, but she advised us to start with one and to see how we feel because she said it was common that people's eyes were bigger than their stomachs when it came to the restaurant). We took her advice and boy was she right!! We needed to be rolled out the door after that dessert sampler and would never have been able to take a few bites of anything else.
I feel like 4-stars might be more appropriate for this place but the prices feel a smidge too high. I've only been here once, so I will dutifully go again to see if the service is as awesome as the first time to see about bumping this up to 4!