Meh! A bit disappointed. A friend of ours had ordered from here during one of the Steeler games. The food had been fresh and good. Hoping for the same we tried it for dinner tonight. The Vodka pizza and wood fired wings left me wanting. The flatbread crust was too hard and the wings were 'icky' dry.
When places like this that have the potential to be good lack consistency it saddens the foodie in me. I'm giving it a 3 keeping my first experience in mind. Not sure if anything in future would compel me to give City Oven another go.