My first time there with a party of 3 we just went for hot drinks on a cold day. My hot cocoa came lukewarm, but I didn't feel like making a big deal of it. Halfway through someone else mentioned his coffee came lukewarm and the 3rd said her coffee was as well. Very disappointing. One star.
This weekend we walked down Roncy looking for a late lunch. Most places were closed by 3 pm, so we stopped into Butler's as a last choice option. This time the cappuccino came piping hot. I got the egyptian dish, which was both tasty and very filling. Partner got the Jambalaya, which he thought was just ok. We both agreed the house dressing was fantastic. This was a 3 star experience.
Averaging the 2 experiences together would only be 2 stars, but the 2nd time was good enough to make us think we'd still give it another try.