We had our wedding rings made here a few years ago and I have only positive things to say about our experience at Made You Look. The in-store staff was very helpful and friendly, not trying to push you on a sale, just letting you look around, but always there if you needed a question answered.
When we did make our decision, the jeweler was there to meet with us and discuss what we wanted. Even though our rings were not among the most expensive they had to offer, they took care of us with a lot of care and friendliness. They do have a wide selection of different jewelry through dozens of local designers with a price to seemingly meet everyone's varying budgets.
It should be noted, there are two Made You Look stores, nearly straight across Queen St from each other. One houses more jewelry and the other houses a bit more craft-based looking items. Both are great shops to just browse through, even if you're not sure what you're looking for yet.
Overall, one of the better shopping experiences I've had in Toronto was at Made You Look. Highly recommended you drop in and check out their useful website.