There are two things to know before you go to Pickle Barrel. 1) The menu is long and extensive 2) So are their meals ... If you're not sure what you want to eat you should go here because they'll probably have something to satisfy your hunger with. On the downside, if you go here hungry and don't know what you want to eat you'll probably eat everything you order and be full for the next 3 days.
What I can recommend right off the bat without thinking are a few things that I know are good... they aren't in a specific order just what I can think about off the top of my head. I should note though that the menu can be scary to go through because it's a little TOO long.
1) Chicken Fingers..either with fries or their Greek Salad... this is a classic and you can't go wrong..so if you want to be safe this is good.
2) Greek Salad... you can have it for yourself or share it with the table as an appetizer... **Warning this salad is REALLY big
3) Luau Salad... really nice summer salad
4) PB Sliders
5) Avocado Turkey Club... this is ridiculously good
6) Waffle with fresh berries or banana served with frozen yogurt
7) BBQ Haven... really big meal and really good..
During the week I think on Tuesday they have cheap Bellini's so it's can be nice to go for lunch or dinner... if Bellini's are your thing..and their martini's are really strong at this location. I know random ordering a martini at pickle barrel but if you're looking something that's going to hit you over a meal I'd suggest PB.
Every time I've been at the Yonge and Eg location the service has been great.
Also if you park in the mall you can get your parking validated.