Holy crap how had I never been here before?!
My friend talks about how good it is all the time. I figured she was right, but I'm pretty picky when it comes to certain things: like mac n cheese. If it's not amazing, I'm unimpressed. Same with blue cheese dressing.
This place does not even look like it would have better than slightly-above-average food. I loved the low-key biker bar feel. I did not expect everything to taste quite as good as it did. The buffalo chicken sandwich had just the right thickness for a bun - not too much; I hate when it's so bready the sandwich seems dry. Nope, not a problem here. The fries were good and not overly-salted (in fact, I added a little salt, which is rare for me). The buffalo sauce was delicious, and the blue cheese dressing was homemade and so good.
I tasted a bite of my friend's mac n cheese and she's lucky I didn't just grab the rest off of her plate ...
The only downfall to our visit is our food took quite a long time to come out. But the owner apologized to us and the waitress said the kitchen was just really backed up. My friend didn't indicate that this was a regular problem, so no big deal.
My only problem is going to be what to order next time! Everything else on the menu looks so good, too!