Yaay!! 4 stars says it, yo. Though I don't get where people are finding the $$ pricing, this place is SO affordable. I had chicken and waffles ($10, whaaat!!), reisling (solid), and a friggin ridiculous blueberry crepe and some zesty coffee. My dad loved his rueben and pale ale. What I am even more excited about is coming back for the brunch and the supposedly New York Style pizza. Another hidden gem.
Also, we tried sitting outside and the wind blew our water all over the table and the menus were flying all over the place. The staff was SO nice and apologetic, even though it wasn't their fault. Needless to say we sat inside after that, but for a "tavern," it's a pretty cute atmosphere.