First of all let me say hey if you look at my profile you will see my hometown is Pittsburgh so when I occasionally go back for a visit I want every dining experience to be great especially one for a new comer like Wintzell's. That said it was disappointing, after two visits over the past several months the best I can say is that it was just OK, which for me is lackluster.
Let's see the first trip with my wife we both ordered a dozen oysters and they were so bad we sent them back - WTF they do call them selves an oyster house right? My second visit last week with my two sisters we all had a lobster tail special and it was just OK. And, why would they establish an adjoining cigar bar right next to the restaurant I have no idea, although it looked cool, these things are white elephants in this day and age.
I will say the staff was friendly, efficient and willing to please but that's about it.