Whenever I think of NY Pizza, I think of tiny, hole-in-the-wall places that have been slinging slices for decades. It also doesn't help that the NY Pizza I was used to in college came from this tiny place where you could barely walk through (one shoulder's width) wide for customers, but you would grab a slice and enjoy it (all techniques welcome: the fold, plate hold, tiny bites (to keep from burning the roof of your mouth), etc).
This New York Pizza is located off of South Blvd.... plenty of places to park and it pretty clean and impressive inside. I think the first thing that struck me were the TV's (maybe cause they were new), but you order at the counter and the pizza's come out to you, nice and hot.
Folks working here were nice and there was a steady stream of customers coming in (great sign). We dinned in, but it looked like a lot of people called in and picked up... Not sure if they deliver... but I believe I live too far away from here to take advantage of that if they did.
Our group of 6/7 people split a salad and two pies. Both were pretty darn amazing. One was a pepperoni, banana pepper, and onion and the other was a sausage and mushroom pizza. Solid crust - definitely key in delivering the toppings, sauces, and cheeses. Looks like they also have calzones, pizza by the slice (pepperoni, cheese, some specialty), grinders, and some other items not pizza.