TWO WORDS: Pirogi Pizza.
Haha. Just kidding...sort of. I ordered this pizza by chance (serendipity?) the first time I came to this location and I've had to fight my brain really hard (often in vain) to try to order something else on return visits. It's a pizza layered with spicy potatoes (scalloped?) covered with cheese, bacon, and green onions and a bit of sour cream to cool the potatoes. It's surprisingly awesome.
All the other pizza is always pretty good here if not mind blowing. The house sauce in particular is pretty top notch. The other food is pretty good in a sort of Kelseys/Pickle Barrel/Jack Astor's average kind of way.
I've come here for lunch a few times from work and the lunch menu has a couple decent pastas and lunch sized pizzas on it.
My issue here has been with service on multiple occasions. Once or twice I've had issue even getting someone at the front entrance to seat us. On one occasion at a work lunch my boss had to wander around the restaurant to find our waiter to pay after being left alone for 15 minutes. Boo. Was going to be a 4, until I remembered all the issues I've had getting service here in the past.