Very solid 4, maybe even a 4.5.
Service - very attentive and even handled our indecisiveness and at times obnoxious humor well with our party of 7
Also, very accommodating. We were the tough table with a million requests, everyone talking loud and over each other, and complaints about the temperature. They moved us and handled all the nuances of our party exceptionally well.
Atmosphere - A little cold if you're under the vent and hot if you're not, but the servers and manager acknowledges and tried to adjust.
Really cool looking place. Noisy, but semi-casual yet comfortable too.
Food - What really matters and they were solid across the board. We started with pork shoulder and meatballs. The meatballs were hard enough on the outside with an absolutely amazing sauce. The wild rice was also delicious. Everyone in the crew liked their dishes: trout, salmon, portobello burger, chicken, and lamb. The lamb and trout went without anyone else getting a bite. Chicken was a little dry outside the wings, but still tasty.
Brussels sprouts, asparagus, and coleslaw were also on par with expectations.
Drinks - very different, but everyone went for second rounds. Beers and cocktails $5 drafts Thursday.
Will be coming back. Fo sho.