The price of $2 is fabulous for a treat and the woman that put together my order was friendly and helpful, so these aspects should garner a higher rating, but the blandness of the cookies (one chocolate chip and one peanut butter) and the ice cream were a major disappointment. If I'm going to consume the (I assume high-ish) calories, I want to be wowed by the flavors.
I recommend giving this place a try anyway because everyone has different tastes and it seems like a lot of people like this place.