We went for dinner. I ordered the seared tuna, he ordered the burger. The tuna was ok and the burger seemed more well-received. We were looking for a nice dinner out on a Friday night, and I think the problem was that it wasn't the kind of place we were looking for. From reading the other reviews, it seems like this is a popular brunch spot. We also noticed they had won "Best Lunch" in Madison, so I think we just chose incorrectly for a nice dinner out! We will give it another try since we live so close by.