I've been here three times, and my final conclusion is: meh. It's not awful, but it's not worth the high prices either. It's very nicely decorated inside though and our waitress couldn't have been better.
My latest visit we ordered ceviche to share. It had no citrus flavor and the chunks of fish and scallops were very tough and fishy. The shrimp in it was ok, but this wasn't nearly as good as the civiche at Mitchell's.
I had a blackberry red sangria which was pretty good and reasonably priced at $6.00.
I had the Lily's chicken for dinner, because fish and chips, and crab cakes on past visits weren't great. The chicken had wayyyy too many greens on top, and the goat cheese was very sour. And I love goat cheese. Their mashed potatoes are very good.
Three of us shared the macadamia brownie...it was a very small portion for the price and was more like a crumbly cake than a brownie. Another "meh" moment.
Someone got the sirloin and crabcake dinner and really liked it, and another in our party got the salmon with mango salsa and said "it's just ok" when asked.
The 5 year old tore up the popcorn shrimp and fries.
Two of us put our food on the same check. We had $55 in gift cards between us and still had to pay $20 each. Almost $100 for a shared appetizer, 2 dinners, a sangria, and a shared dessert. All of which, except the sangria and mashed potatoes, were just mediocre? No.
There are too many great places around with reliably good food to go back here. While i don't hate it here, i don't love it either. For the price, I'll stay with Mitchell's or Bahama breeze!