Every baked good that I have ever tried at the Arcade Bakery has been absolutely superb. The thumbprint cookies are my favorite and are a must try item. I have also enjoyed the doughnuts, brownies, and sugar cookies. The downtown Macy's (formerly Kaufmann's) has an awesome retro vibe, and the Arcade fits right in with its old school downtown quality. Seating and space is somewhat limited, so you might want to plan your visit for an off peak time.