Not for me. I've had a cookie dough or two. This one doesn't hit the mark for me. It tastes like they might use pre-made base (flour, sugar and butter) then just jazz it up to make multiple flavors. I ended up getting ice-cream after sampling 3 doughs and not liking them. The ice-cream while fudgey didn't taste like malt at all. I adore cookie dough and while the spot looks just like what old town loves. I can't, if I want ice-cream I'll go hit up the sugar bowl! Sorry guys! Best of luck!