I'd give the Peach Stand five stars, if only the staff were better.
As another yelper noted, the girls can sometimes have a very poor attitude. I have a major problem when a clerk doesn't offer the obvious (a bag for multiple items), or when they don't thank the customer for their business and/or wish them a nice day.
Now that the griping is done :): The Peach Stand's ice cream is good, but not exceptional. Their baked goods are exceptional: pies are fresh, tasty, homemade, not too sweet, but not too bland; fair priced. Much of what they sell is locally sourced, yet reasonably priced.
This is the best place to pick up dessert for a dinner date. They're open until 9, and they're conveniently located.
I'd frequent The Peach Stand more often, if not for the poor attitudes of (some) of the employees.