i really can't understand all the bad reviews, but i wasn't there for the experiences so it's not in my place to criticize them. however, my experience here was different, and quite pleasant. first, the owner is japanese, so you know you're getting authentic japanese food. second, the sushi chef, as well as the cook are japanese, so it's definitely legit.
the problem with this place is perhaps the signs outside advertising AYCE and the pricing, as well as the "free food on your birthday" gimic. i mean, let's face it, when eating establishments market itself in such a way, it does make you wonder about the quality of food being served.
that said, as i've stated above, my experience was pleasant. i ordered the AYCE sushi for 25 bucks, and had the omakase, which was wonderful. i also had a salad, miso soup, tempura, spring roll, and for dessert - green tea ice cream. not bad at all, in fact i felt very at home and warm inside.
i can't wait to tell my parents about this little neighborhood gem of a sushi shop that i've discovered.