I liked the variety of sandwiches available. My mom and I each got something different and then traded a half so we could sample a couple of them. By far my favorite thing was the fried zucchini with pesto dipping sauce. The zucchini was perfectly fried deliciousness and the pesto was fresh and wonderful. The girls at the register were friendly, but they did miss a couple of special requests we made. In their defense, we were new to Ike's and asking lots of questions. The mistakes in our order weren't bad enough to complain about or send back the food.
Ultimately, the reason I'm rating Ike's 4 stars and not 5 is price. We felt it was a bit pricey for sandwiches, although they are huge. Two people could easily split one. So if you're a penny pintcher like me, bring a friend and share a sandwich.