Easily the best chocolate in Cleveland, and potentially further out. I brought back some chocolates from Vosges a bit ago and did a comparison to some of the same flavors from Lilly's - and the majority were better than Vosges. For example, Lilly's 40 Winks (lavender and dark chocolate) is slightly less, a little bigger, and (most important) significantly better. why would I pay more to overnight chocolates from Chicago, or stock up from out of town when I can get better stuff ten minutes away? The truffles are fantastic, with a good selection plus they make fantastic chocolate bark!
After trying the pistachio truffle recently, a friend declared that they needed a few minutes alone. Oh, and I haven't even gotten to the booze yet. The recently expanded interior (still has the same vibe and plenty of pink) allows for more wine and beer. If you aren't sure about what to get, the staff has always cheerfully supplied suggestions (for pairings, or just things you might like). Stopping in feels more like seeing friends due to the warmth the staff shows, and you can truly tell how much they care about their store.